Why it would be better if women's day did not exist?
The internet has variety of things, the good, bad and the
ugly. It tells us the truth, facts, opinions, made up stories, and literally
anything that exists or doesn’t exist.
8th of march was celebrated as the
international women’s day. And thus, followed it; thousands of memes, quotes of pride, shame,
fury and laughter. One of these that I happened to notice was a meme on
Instagram which showed a large cheering crowd with “women’s day” written on top
and just one man standing with “men’s day” written on it. When I happened to
immediately diss that Instagram meme, the boy sitting next to me casually said,
“But isn’t that true! Men’s day really does not get even half the importance as
women’s day”. I am a sensitive person who gets irritated without explaining,
who expects people around me to share all the ideologies that’s I have and who
has tolerance of the size of a sand particle. I consider everybody to have
grown in the same environment and with the same upbringing as me. So instead of
calmly putting up my view (the very idea behind men’s day foolish) is , I ended
up shouting at him, the point of which I’m sure, he still would not have
understood. When I told him, that women need empowerment and that is why we
have a day for them, but men are empowered enough already; the idea seemed
abstract to him. The argument he put forward in return was so futile. He was
quick to compare empowerment with dominance and just like those 50 years old
uncles whose WhatsApp forwards are of jokes on their innocent wives’ lack of
cooking skills, or brains or conceited nature, said, “Wives are more dominant
everywhere”. Answers like these enrage me because this is not the environment,
I wish to be in.
The mere existence of Women’s day is a matter of shame. It
exists not because there is a day for everyone. It started because just 100
years ago that women’s suffrage took place even in superpowers like “The United
States of America” which this dear friend of mine, knowingly or unknowingly, is
so influenced by. Empowerment is needed because even today a 25 years old man
would consider himself to be wiser than 50-year-old women. It is needed because
one poor lady in a remote village somewhere is restricted to her suffocating
kitchen, because her husband is not accountable to her, but she is accountable
to him, because she cannot be autonomous. Social conditioning still exists not
only based on the bodily abilities but other orthodox traditions although they
make little sense.
Women need empowerment so that they can be dragged up to be
at par with men, not so that they can replace men by where they stand now. When
someone falls into a pit, they are given a ladder to come up to the surface. Now
this does not mean that the people in the surface will complain that they
weren’t given the ladder and therefore the system is partial. So, my dear
classmate and all the men who complain about the women’s compartment in the
train - you don’t need the ladder because you already stand on the surface and
giving you one would just further increase the gap between you and the pit
fallen women (same goes for the Dalits with reservation or the LGBTQ community).
Giving women the social, political and economic pull is to bring them on the
same line as men. So, as Gloria Steinem says, if there is any pull you need it
is for you to say, “I can do whatever a woman can”.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLoved the ladder analogy
ReplyDeleteWell written Shweta
Well written Puja. Keep it up.
ReplyDeleteI agree that having a designated day for women is also an indication of the imbalance in society acts as both as a reminder of both of the past but a starker reminder of how longer we have to go.
A much more effective approach would be to have a Man's day and on that day men are perhaps asked to perform a task or activity that a woman performs daily.
This way men are pushed out of their comfort zones and talk stock of this imbalance.
Equity must precede equality and it is only common sense that it should. It is high time that this is understood in all contexts in the right spirit. So heartening to see that you have touched upon it beautifully in your post, Puja. More power to you!
ReplyDelete